To see accurate pricing, please choose your delivery country.
 
 
United States
£ GBP
All Shops

British Wildlife

8 issues per year 84 pages per issue Subscription only

British Wildlife is the leading natural history magazine in the UK, providing essential reading for both enthusiast and professional naturalists and wildlife conservationists. Published eight times a year, British Wildlife bridges the gap between popular writing and scientific literature through a combination of long-form articles, regular columns and reports, book reviews and letters.

Subscriptions from £33 per year

Conservation Land Management

4 issues per year 44 pages per issue Subscription only

Conservation Land Management (CLM) is a quarterly magazine that is widely regarded as essential reading for all who are involved in land management for nature conservation, across the British Isles. CLM includes long-form articles, events listings, publication reviews, new product information and updates, reports of conferences and letters.

Subscriptions from £26 per year
Good Reads  Environmental & Social Studies  Economics, Politics & Policy  Economics, Business & Industry  Economics, Business & Industry: General

The Value of a Whale On the Illusions of Green Capitalism

By: Adrienne Buller(Author)
350 pages, no illustrations
NHBS
The Value of a Whale is a necessary corrective to the green capitalist solutions to address climate change.
The Value of a Whale
Click to have a closer look
Average customer review
  • The Value of a Whale ISBN: 9781526162632 Paperback Jul 2022 Not in stock: Usually dispatched within 1-2 weeks
    £12.99
    #255629
Price: £12.99
About this book Contents Customer reviews Biography Related titles Recommended titles

About this book

Nature is collapsing at an unprecedented rate. Despite countless pledges and summits, we remain on course for a catastrophic 3°C of warming. And in a world of immense wealth, billions still live below the poverty line – and on the frontlines of environmental breakdown. Increasingly, the world is waking up this reality, but are the 'solutions' being proposed really solutions?

In this searing and insightful critique, Adrienne Buller examines the escalating plunder of the natural world under financial capitalism, and exposes the fatal biases that have shaped climate and environmental policymaking. Tracing the intricate connections between financial power, vested interests and environmental governance, she exposes the myopic economism and market-centric thinking presently undermining a future where all life can flourish. Both honest and optimistic, The Value of a Whale asks us – in the face of crisis – what we really value.

Contents

Introduction: What's the value of a whale?

1. The tragedy of the horizon
2. Sleepwalkers and seers: How finance shapes the future
3. Alchemists: What's green is gold
4. On borrowed time: From repayment to reparation
5. Whales and white elephants: On the financialisation of nature
6. Living in the age of BlackRock

Epilogue: On the value of the whale
References
Index

Customer Reviews (1)

  • A shocking and necessary corrective
    By Leon (NHBS Catalogue Editor) 25 Sep 2023 Written for Paperback


    In an attempt to address climate change and other environmental problems, governments are increasingly turning. The underlying message is clear: capitalism might have created the problem, but capitalism can solve it. Adrienne Buller, a Senior Fellow with progressive think tank Common Wealth, is, to put it mildly, sceptical of this. From carbon credits to biodiversity offsets, she unmasks these policies for the greenwashing that they are. The Value of a Whale is a necessary corrective that is as eye-opening as it is shocking.

    As Buller defines it here, green capitalism sees governments and corporations pursue ideas and policies that use the logic and force of economic markets to address environmental problems. It has two defining characteristics that she returns to throughout the book (and I am paraphrasing here): whatever you do, do not disrupt the existing economy, and while we are at it, let us turn crises into new opportunities to get filthy rich. The book roughly breaks down into two halves: the odd chapters provide background information on how the global economy works while the even chapters critically evaluate several green capitalist solutions. Before I discuss some notable examples, it is useful to mention what is not in the book. This is not an account of the people undermining the scientific consensus. As she points out, those merchants of doubt have been covered at length elsewhere. Nor is this a manifesto of solutions, though in the process of exposing our failures, she outlines some of the necessary changes.

    Let me first highlight the background chapters as they give a useful indication of the kinds of people and ideas that are coming to the table when it comes to formulating "solutions". There were various things here that I found eye-opening and even shocking, though I will gladly concede my ignorance of economics and the inner workings of the global financial system. Readers more familiar with these topics might not be as surprised as I was.

    For example, you would think that the idea of limiting global warming to 2°C above pre-industrial levels is based on the best available science. Instead, Buller traces it back to a 1975 thought experiment by the influential economist William Nordhaus. Despite some very questionable assumptions, the idea has become a central pillar of climate change policy. Nordhaus is representative of a large group of well-meaning economists who look at climate change strictly through the lens of economics. Their flawed models "that collapse the complexity of our globalised economy, climate and biosphere into improbably simple predictions" (p. 43) are legitimising inaction by politicians. We should call them out for what they are: false prophets. Similarly, why do we seem powerless to hold companies accountable? Because we are. Buller explains how neoliberal reforms from the 1970s onwards were explicitly framed in terms of reigning in democracy and insulating the financial world from popular demands. After all, such interference only stifles economic progress. She discusses other facets of the global financial system, but this should give you a taste of the background against which climate change policy is being formulated.

    Let me discuss one example that Buller examines in detail: putting a price on carbon emissions, whether through a tax or a carbon market where companies can buy credits to continue emissions. Superficially it sounds fair (the polluter pays) and prominent economists adamantly assert that it is the only way to combat climate change. But does it work? Shockingly, despite over a decade of policies, very few studies have assessed the results and those that did found almost no emission reductions. Why can it not work? For one, our society is completely built around fossil fuels and cannot be changed overnight, thus carbon pricing should come not at the start, but at the end of this process when we have alternative infrastructure to switch to. Another reason is that pricing mechanisms do not care whether results stem from fundamental changes or easy efficiency gains (e.g. burning gas instead of coal). Furthermore, attempts to offset continued emissions by, say, tree planting initiatives come with their own suite of problems. At its most obscene, continued emissions are accompanied by promises of unproven technofixes that will mop up all this excess carbon in the near future. Why is this still being promoted? It is wonderful PR for companies, while for politicians it is a solution that avoids difficult confrontations with the industry. Also, when market approaches do fail, "the sheer volume of actors involved distributes accountability by design" (p. 75), so nobody needs to take any blame.

    Despite The Value of a Whale being an exposé that skewers green capitalism, it is refreshing to see that Buller remains reasonable. She will happily concede where mainstream economists have a point and she admits that, in principle, there is nothing wrong with using economic insights to inform our response to climate change. However, upon closer inspection almost all ideas are "thwarted by the messiness of reality [and] the physical constraints of nature" (p. 58). Buller's overarching conclusion is not just that green capitalist solutions do not work, but that they cannot work. Why? Because they perpetuate the fallacies of mainstream economics; that we behave as rational economic actors (we do not) who come to the market with equal power (we do not, companies constantly overrule whole segments of the population). Because capitalism proceeds by externalising costs; internalising the cost of climate change while making a profit from it necessarily generates new externalities. Because financial markets optimize for efficient rather than effective solutions; as long as it makes money it does not matter to financiers that it does not work. Because economic models usually consider climate and ecological changes as gradual and predictable processes; climate scientists instead warn of unpredictable interactions, positive feedback loops, and tipping points.

    Should we nevertheless accept green capitalist solutions? Is something better than nothing? For Buller, acceptable solutions should have an actual material impact, i.e. slow or reverse emissions or biodiversity loss. But they should also redistribute wealth and power more fairly. In her view, unequal affluence stimulates more consumption across the board. The green capitalist solutions discussed here fail on both accounts. We are wasting time on solutions that are a distraction at best and a fatal deception at worst.

    Though I found it technical in a few places, The Value of a Whale is an eye-opening critique that I expect to be recommending frequently in the future.
    Was this helpful to you? Yes No

Biography

Adrienne Buller is a Senior Fellow at Common Wealth, a progressive think tank focused on the democratic economy. Her writing has featured in The Guardian, The Financial Times, The New Statesman, Jacobin, and New Left Review.

By: Adrienne Buller(Author)
350 pages, no illustrations
NHBS
The Value of a Whale is a necessary corrective to the green capitalist solutions to address climate change.
Media reviews

"Why do so many of the alleged solutions to climate crisis fail to deliver? In this tightly-argued, precise and deeply-researched book Adrienne Buller looks inside the heads of 'green' capitalists, exposing how non-solutions proliferate. Read this brilliant expose if you want to understand not only how some of the world's most powerful people think and act but also how their solutions differ from what is really needed to secure a safe and abundant future for everyone."
– Amelia Horgan, author of Lost in Work

"This is a witty, lucid and beautifully written critique of that contradiction-in-terms, 'green capitalism'. It explains why, despite the farcical diminuendo of climate denialism, so little has changed. Its searching inquiry into the puritanical reduction of all living matter to economic value, which underpins most government responses to ecological catastrophe, incisively debunks one of the most dangerous illusions going. This is the book we have long needed."
– Richard Seymour, author of The Twittering Machine

"A wonderfully readable attack on the worldview that argues for adding a dollar value to nature in order to save it. An accessible account of a new phase of capitalism that we all need to understand."
– Professor Simon Lewis, author of The Human Planet

"At last! A wonderfully refreshing antidote to the notion that market forces can solve the climate and nature crises, and the deadly assumption that every idea must be evaluated in terms of markets, finance, property or profit. Elegant, incisive and fierce, Buller systematically takes apart the false solutions that dominate mainstream analysis, from carbon offsets to the commodification of nature, and gives us the tools to challenge their dominance and to broaden our understanding of what's both possible and necessary."
– Caroline Lucas MP

"Buller offers essential context for understanding how economic dogmas and market-driven statecraft have warped our understanding of and responses to the climate crisis – or lack thereof. Crucially, she also presents a practical roadmap for course-correction. The Value of a Whale is an accessible and expertly curated guide to the increasingly slick, green face of capitalism in the 21st century. This book should be required reading for everyone from climate activists to policymakers and concerned citizens looking to salvage our collective prospects for a liveable future."
– Kate Aronoff, author of Overheated

"This is a book for anyone troubled by our lack of progress on the climate crisis, from young activists to hard-headed CEOs and investors that face losing control of companies as the climate breaks down. In her persuasive analysis of net zero policies that narrowly prioritise efficiency, market pricing and offsetting – and with unusual clarity and scrupulous integrity – Buller comes to unsettling conclusions. Read this before it is too late."
– Ann Pettifor, author of The Case for the Green New Deal

"The Value of a Whale is an urgent and honest intervention, casting a magnifying glass over the institutions, insider groupthink, and non-solutions distracting and deflecting from the radical ideas and compassion we need to secure a safe planetary future. For too long, our response to ecological crisis has been steered by mainstream economic thinking that is not fit for purpose, to the exclusion of other vital perspectives. As Buller compellingly argues, we are long overdue a reset."
– Farhana Yamin, Visiting Professor at UAK, Associate Fellow, Chatham House

"A sorely needed corrective in an era of climate politics dominated by dollars and models. Adrienne Buller's The Value of a Whale is critical reading for the important task of prying the future out of the hands of corporations and technocrats."
– Olúfemi O. Táíwò, author of Elite Capture and Reconsidering Reparations

Current promotions
Field Guide SaleNHBS Moth TrapNew and Forthcoming BooksBuyers Guides