All Shops
We're still open for business, read our Covid-19 statement here

British Wildlife

6 issues per year 84 pages per issue Subscription only

British Wildlife is the leading natural history magazine in the UK, providing essential reading for both enthusiast and professional naturalists and wildlife conservationists. Published six times a year, British Wildlife bridges the gap between popular writing and scientific literature through a combination of long-form articles, regular columns and reports, book reviews and letters.

Subscriptions from £30 per year

Conservation Land Management

4 issues per year 44 pages per issue Subscription only

Conservation Land Management (CLM) is a quarterly magazine that is widely regarded as essential reading for all who are involved in land management for nature conservation, across the British Isles. CLM includes long-form articles, events listings, publication reviews, new product information and updates, reports of conferences and letters.

Subscriptions from £18 per year
Academic & Professional Books  Earth System Sciences  Hydrosphere  Water Resources & Management  Marine Resources & Management

Ocean Recovery A Sustainable Future for Global Fisheries?

By: Ray Hilborn(Author), Ulrike Hilborn(Author)
196 pages, b/w illustrations, tables
NHBS
A thought-provoking and nuanced book, Ocean Recovery critically and skeptically examines overblown claims of doom while showing where sustainable fisheries management works and where it fails.
Ocean Recovery
Click to have a closer look
Average customer review
  • Ocean Recovery ISBN: 9780198839767 Hardback Jun 2019 In stock
    £28.99
    #246080
Price: £28.99
About this book Contents Customer reviews Biography Related titles

About this book

Over the last two decades, the scientific and popular media have been bombarded by gloom and doom stories of the future of fisheries, the status of fish stocks, and the impact of fishing on marine ecosystems. Dozens of certification and labeling schemes have emerged to advise consumers on what seafood is sustainable. In recent years, an opposing narrative has emerged emphasizing the success of fisheries management in many places, the increasing abundance of fish stocks in those places, and the prescription for sustainable fisheries. However, there has been no comprehensive survey of what really constitutes sustainability in fisheries, fish stock status, success and failures of management, and consideration of the impacts of fishing on marine ecosystems. Ocean Recovery will explore very different perspectives on sustainability, and bring together the data from a large number of studies to show where fish stocks are increasing, where they are declining, the consequences of alternative fisheries management regimes, and what is known about a range of fisheries issues such as the impacts of trawling on marine ecosystems.

Contents

1: The Bristol Bay salmon fishery
2: Fisheries sustainability
3: How fisheries are managed
4: Who gets to fish?
5: The global status of fisheries: a long tale of scientists, opinions, papers written and refuted, all in the pursuit of the same truth
6: The environmental impacts of fishing
7: Recreational fishing
8: Freshwater fisheries
9: Mixed species fishing and bycatch
10: Bottom trawling
11: The forage fish rollercoaster
12: Following the rules and illegal fishing
13: Seafood certification and NGOs
14: Ecosystem based management and marine protected areas
15: Enhancement and aquaculture
16: Climate change
17: The future of fisheries

Customer Reviews (1)

  • Thought-provoking and nuanced
    By Leon (NHBS Catalogue Editor) 24 Feb 2020 Written for Hardback


    Overfishing is a topic I can get particularly fired up about. But how bad is the situation really? Am I buying too much into the stories of gloom, doom, and impending fisheries collapse that is the bread and butter of environmental organisations? Ocean Recovery is a short and snappy book by fisheries scientist Ray Hilborn that offers a more nuanced picture. While highlighting that there are serious problems and there is plenty of room for improvement, he shows fishing can be, and in many places is, sustainable. The book certainly challenged some of my preconceived notions with a healthy reality check.

    Looking over the chapter headings reveals the role of co-author Ulrike Hilborn. She has acted as jargon buster and smoothed out Ray’s text into something very accessible. The first few chapters introduce common concepts in fisheries, such as Maximum Sustainable Yield (MSY), Individual Transferable Quotas (ITQs), and different management strategies. Especially MSY (the idea that you catch as many fish as possible now without eating into future catches) has been severely criticised (see e.g. All the Fish in the Sea). Part of the problem, Hilborn writes, is that it is easily misused. If you take it to be a fixed value, you are doing it wrong – fish populations naturally go through long-term boom-bust cycles that are still poorly understood, so this should be a continuous management process.

    The remainder of the book examines oft-mentioned negative impacts of marine fisheries. Two groups, in particular, come in for criticism: fellow scientists preaching doom and gloom (and the news outlets who lap up these stories), and environmental NGOs whose intentions are good, but who are paving a road to hell with them.

    Overfishing made headlines with a 2006 Science publication that was widely reported along the lines of “Seafood May Be Gone by 2048“. Except that fisheries scientists mean something else with the term “collapse”. More to the point, this extrapolation is by no means certain. It allows Hilborn to examine the status of fisheries worldwide (see also his book Overfishing: What Everyone Needs to Know). Where proper management is now in place (the USA, Europe, Australia, New Zealand), the majority of exploited fish stocks are stable or increasing. For most of Asia, Africa and South America, however, data is missing, overfishing rife, and the picture grim. Overfishing does happen, but with proper management it can also be remediated, is Hilborn’s more nuanced message. Though I continue to wonder about shifting baselines, and how impoverished the current stabilised states are compared to the past.

    Two other examples of overstated negative impacts might equally surprise you. First, Daniel Pauly (see also my review of Vanishing Fish) wrote one of the most-cited papers in fisheries science, claiming we are fishing down food webs. Soon, only small fish and marine invertebrates will remain. But a response looking at the actual trophic level of caught fish – where they reside in the food web – concluded that Pauly was simply wrong. Hilborn’s summary is somewhat scant here, so I would have to follow up his references before being fully convinced. Second, trawling. Yes, it has a large impact, although different fishing gear design and best practices can reduce the most egregious side effects such as by-catch. However, Hilborn’s explanation of why the size of affected areas has been miscounted and exaggerated stands out for its clarity.

    Other topics covered include the underestimated and overlooked impact of both sports fishing and commercial freshwater fisheries, mistakes made and lessons learned in aquaculture (fish farming), and the need to enforce rules and tackle the enormous problem of illegal fishing. Regarding that last one: Hilborn’s proposed measures all look good on paper, but after having reviewed The Outlaw Ocean I do not feel hopeful we will tackle this one quickly or easily.

    The second group to come in for a healthy dollop of criticism are a number of environmental NGOs. Two areas that Hilborn highlights are, first, the various seafood certification schemes that often disagree with each other whether or not certain fish species are “safe” to eat (i.e. sustainably fished), causing confusion. And second, Marine Protected Areas (MPAs).

    Wait, what?

    At first glance, this may seem unbelievable. But follow his logic, examine the data, and you might just change your mind. To be clear, Hilborn thinks that MPAs have a role to play, e.g. in heavily overfished areas in Asia. Instead, Western countries, pressured by NGOs, are banning fishing in currently well-managed areas. The only thing this achieves is displacement, increasing the fishing pressure outside of MPAs. And since many fish species wander widely, this can actually have a negative overall effect. Worse, industries move to waters where regulations are laxer. “Warm and fuzzy righteousness does have consequences”, Hilborn remarks.

    This topic of displacement came up in my review of The Irresponsible Pursuit of Paradise, but it is such an important and overlooked aspect that I will bang on about it again here. Unless we simultaneously reduce resource consumption, protecting an area from resource extraction is a hollow victory if the extractive industries are displaced to areas with less oversight and regulations.

    This book will no doubt upset some environmentalists, and it is easy to see why. Hilborn is pragmatic. Whereas biologists often focus exclusively on species protection, for Hilborn sustainable development is about reaching a compromise between that and our need to eat. “Everyone has to eat and eating invariably causes some kind of death”, he points out. And by many measures of impact, fishing is lighter on the environment than livestock husbandry and even agriculture.

    As an observation, having reviewed Abundant Earth, Hilborn’s pragmatism also blatantly shows in his language. Referring to fish as "stocks to be exploited" shows he thinks of our ecosystems as humanity’s larder. If you are on board with that (no doubt a big if for some), Hilborn’s rational and nuanced writing is most welcome. His arguing that we ought to be good stewards of this larder rather than plundering it, and how to do that (“stop fishing so hard, and stocks will rebuild”); his acknowledgement of the many problems that do exist, of the amount of work fisheries scientists still have cut out for them, of the surprises that the future will have in store due to climate change... All of these made me feel that this book lived up to the impartial presentation promised on the dust jacket. Ocean Recovery is a thought-provoking read that made me re-think some of my own preconceptions. Any book that does that is worth your time.
    2 of 2 found this helpful - Was this helpful to you? Yes No

Biography

Ray Hilborn is a Professor in the School of Aquatic and Fishery Sciences, University of Washington specializing in natural resource management and conservation. He teaches graduate and undergraduate courses in food sustainability, conservation, and quantitative population dynamics. He has co-authored several books including Overfishing: What Everyone Needs to Know, Quantitative Fisheries Stock Assessment, and The Ecological Detective: Confronting Models with Data and has published over 300 peer reviewed articles. He has served on the Editorial Boards of numerous journals including 7 years on the Board of Reviewing Editors of Science Magazine. He has received the Volvo Environmental Prize, the American Fisheries Societies Award of Excellence, The Ecological Society of America's Sustainability Science Award, and the International Fisheries Science Prize. He is a Fellow of the American Fisheries Society, the Royal Society of Canada, and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.

Ulrike Hilborn is a writer and has worked with her husband, Ray, for over 40 years.

By: Ray Hilborn(Author), Ulrike Hilborn(Author)
196 pages, b/w illustrations, tables
NHBS
A thought-provoking and nuanced book, Ocean Recovery critically and skeptically examines overblown claims of doom while showing where sustainable fisheries management works and where it fails.
Current promotions
Spring Promotions 2020WILDGuidesNest Box Price List 2020Order your free copy of our 2020 equipment catalogue