To see accurate pricing, please choose your delivery country.
 
 
United States
£ GBP
All Shops

British Wildlife

8 issues per year 84 pages per issue Subscription only

British Wildlife is the leading natural history magazine in the UK, providing essential reading for both enthusiast and professional naturalists and wildlife conservationists. Published eight times a year, British Wildlife bridges the gap between popular writing and scientific literature through a combination of long-form articles, regular columns and reports, book reviews and letters.

Subscriptions from £33 per year

Conservation Land Management

4 issues per year 44 pages per issue Subscription only

Conservation Land Management (CLM) is a quarterly magazine that is widely regarded as essential reading for all who are involved in land management for nature conservation, across the British Isles. CLM includes long-form articles, events listings, publication reviews, new product information and updates, reports of conferences and letters.

Subscriptions from £26 per year
Good Reads  History & Other Humanities  Anthropology  Linguistics

Talking Heads The New Science of How Conversation Shapes Our Worlds

Popular Science
By: Shane O'Mara(Author)
240 pages
Publisher: The Bodley Head
NHBS
Talking Heads defends the intriguing thesis that human conversation is a powerful yet underappreciated force that shapes many aspects of our lives.
Talking Heads
Click to have a closer look
Average customer review
  • Talking Heads ISBN: 9781847926487 Hardback Aug 2023 Not in stock: Usually dispatched within 6 days
    £21.99
    #264114
Price: £21.99
About this book Customer reviews Biography Related titles

About this book

From neurons to nations, Talking Heads is a stunning survey of the science of human connection and communication

We are social animals and talking is part of what makes us human.

But what purpose does conversation serve? In this revelatory tour of talking, neuroscientist Shane O'Mara explores why we communicate, what happens in our brains when we do it, and what it means for us as individuals, groups and societies.

How do our thoughts, memories, and conversations change our brains? What does it mean that we spend most of our thinking lives in a five-minute bubble around the present moment? Why does our sense of self solidify with age, even as we grow more forgetful? In what ways do we imagine futures together? And how do our nations begin as conversations?

Moving from the personal to the social and ultimately towards a radical new perspective on the defining phenomenon of our times, populist nationalism, this is the story of how conversation builds the worlds around us – and how, together, we can talk our way into a better tomorrow.

Customer Reviews (1)

  • An intriguing idea
    By Leon (NHBS Catalogue Editor) 8 Mar 2024 Written for Hardback


    Several recent books on animal communication highlight that we routinely underestimate animals but also agree that human language really is unique and unlike anything heard in other species. So, what is all of our chatter good for? Talking Heads argues that conversation is the glue that bonds us together as the hypersocial animals that we are; a process by which we co-create cognitive realities such as collective memories, cultures, and, if neuroscientist Shane O'Mara is to be believed, even countries.

    What the title of the book does not immediately reveal is the other important ingredient of human language: memory. To have meaningful conversations we draw on (shared) memories. To demonstrate just how fundamental this is, O'Mara opens the book with the case of patient H.M. who became the most tested patient in the history of psychology. After a childhood accident left him suffering from epileptic fits, he underwent experimental brain surgery in 1953 that relieved his epilepsy but caused permanent amnesia, leaving him unable to form new long-term memories. It also made it impossible to have any meaningful conversation with him.

    The first few chapters set the stage by going into the basics of both conversation and memory. For example, what is conversation? At its simplest, it is a dialogue between two people that involves taking turns speaking and listening. In addition, we have an internal conversation, a monologue with ourselves, that psychologists started to access via introspection, then self-reporting, and lately also brain scans. Much of our conversation involves readily sharing personal details and experiences, and we expect the same from our conversational partners, in the process building connection, understanding, and trust. That, of course, draws on memories. A core idea O'Mara posits here is that "a key function of our memories is intimately supporting social communication" (p. 43). However, our memory is notoriously unreliable: it does not record the world as if it were a video camera, we tweak and update it constantly in conversation with others. This list should give you a decent idea of the basics that O'Mara covers here.

    The thrust of Talking Heads is that all this chatter allows us to live hypersocial and highly interdependent lives that see humans create all sorts of cognitive realities and entities. Three of these merit further exploration.

    First is that conversation allows us to form collective memories. Psychologist Sir Frederic Bartlett showed almost a century ago that memory is about more than just reciting bare facts; there is a strong social side to it and we are compulsive storytellers (something scientists need to be reminded of to this day). No mind is an island and our recollections depend on the people around us. Sociologist Maurice Halbwachs coined the term collective memory for it. So where is memory located then? Two quotations characterise the essence beautifully, I think. First is O'Mara's general observation that "memory emerges from the interaction between the brain and the world" (p. 95). And, regarding cultural knowledge specifically, he adds that it "resides within the brains of the members of that society, but emerges as the result of interactions between members of that society" (p. 102).

    This bridges nicely to the second cognitive reality birthed by our conversations: culture. In a few places, O'Mara reaches back to his opening gambit about amnesia and asks you to imagine that you, or your society, became amnesiacs overnight. How would you pass on any information and customs to the next generation? You could not. This is more than just a goofy thought experiment: the archaeological record is full of signs and symbols that have become uninterpretable and illegible. They have, in the words of neuroscientist Erik Hoel, become epistemologically inaccessible to us. The take-home message is that, for culture to survive over time, you need living, remembering people who engage in conversations. Though O'Mara largely sidesteps any comparisons to animals in this book, I feel it would be remiss of me not to mention the hotly debated topic of animal culture.

    O'Mara's third and most ambitious proposal is "a neuroscience of nation building" (p. 19), the idea that even nations started as conversations. I admit that it has several things going for it. O'Mara agrees with influential political scientist Benedict Anderson that nations are imagined communities: they are cognitive constructs that we imagine together. Nation building involves mental time travel to agree on a shared past and future, appealing to both our memory and our imagination. Nationalist sentiments seem to arise readily given our tribal nature and are a familiar example of a powerful story. Though it unites people, it is easily abused by politicians which is dangerous in light of the abovementioned malleability of our memory. He contrasts nationalism with the historian's craft as instead being a national identity project that is intolerant of ambiguity and counterevidence, and that seeks to protect social identity at all cost, disregarding information that threatens it. O'Mara concludes with a powerful warning: stories of our past are just that, stories, and they primarily serve to buttress our membership of social groups in the here and now.

    That said, as with any ambitious proposal, this one is open to criticism. O'Mara admits early on that writing this book was "an exercise in exclusion" (p. 19), necessarily simplifying some things and omitting others. Though I am not familiar with the literature, I am sure that many other fields have a thing or two to say about nation building. Furthermore, he makes a few statements about the emergence of nations (that they require the loss of authority of scriptural language and biblical texts, as well as the erosion of the divine right of kings) that sound narrowly Eurocentric to me. Did nations not arise elsewhere and at earlier times without the loss of religion? What even counts as a nation and when did this process start? Not offering a definition of a nation seems an oversight.

    Overall, Talking Heads is an intriguing book that is strongest on the psychology and neuroscience of conversation. I especially enjoyed the frequent callouts to the history of the discipline. I think he makes a strong case that conversation is an underappreciated facet that powerfully shapes many aspects of our lives. Especially his argument that "the intensive focus on memory as a personal phenomenon [...] causes us to miss these larger [social] perspectives" (p. 175) is well taken. However, when it comes to explanations for some of humanity's cognitive projects such as nations, conversation strikes me as, well, only one of several narrative strands that would need to be considered.
    Was this helpful to you? Yes No

Biography

Shane O'Mara is Professor of Experimental Brain Research at Trinity College Dublin, the University of Dublin. He is Principal Investigator in, and was director of, the Trinity College Institute of Neuroscience, one of Europe's leading research centres for neuroscience, as well as being a Wellcome Trust Senior Investigator and a Science Foundation Ireland Principal Investigator. He is the author of Why Torture Doesn't Work, A Brain for Business and In Praise of Walking.

His musings on neuroscience, psychology and life can be found at the substack Brain Pizza.

Popular Science
By: Shane O'Mara(Author)
240 pages
Publisher: The Bodley Head
NHBS
Talking Heads defends the intriguing thesis that human conversation is a powerful yet underappreciated force that shapes many aspects of our lives.
Media reviews

"Delightfully well-written, accessible, surprisingly reflecting [...] and humorous"
– Niamh Jimenez, Irish Times

"Surprising [...] intriguing [...] enjoyable"
New Scientist

"In this time of digital disconnection, Talking Heads is a reminder of the enduring power of face-to-face interactions and conversations. It is a thoughtful book that might make you watch what you say."
Irish Independent

"Talking Heads [...] is mostly interested in big-picture questions: how intact memory supports our sociality and binds us into collective beings who share collective memories. [...] The point O'Mara is most keen to make in his book is that entities such as nations 'begin as conversations' [...] O'Mara is an entertaining guide, full of good stories"
Times Literary Supplement

"O'Mara delves deeply into the ways we use conversations to create our cultures and build entire nations [...] There's a lot in it that resonates"
Irish Times

Current promotions
Field Guide SaleNHBS Moth TrapNew and Forthcoming BooksBuyers Guides