Books  Environmental Studies  Philosophy, Ethics & Religion 

The Scalpel and the Butterfly: The Conflict Between Animal Research and Animal Protection

By: Deborah Rudacille

390 pages, no illustrations

University of California Press

Paperback | Sep 2001 | #121441 | ISBN: 0520231546
Temporarily out of stock: order now to get this when available Details
NHBS Price: £26.99 $36/€30 approx

About this book

Examines the ethical question of whether enhancement of human life justifies the use of animals for research.

Rudacille uses impeccably researched material to take readers from the earliest days of animal-rights activism to the present.... In the final chapter, the author embarks on a productive discussion of ways the animal-rights controversy could be resolved. - Rebecca Skloot, Chicago Tribune "We are entering a new era in the question of animal rights. Nowhere is this extremely important issue more cogently discussed than in The Scalpel and the Butterfly. Those who believe, as I do, that animals have rights far beyond those that we at present accord them should arm themselves with the information in this valuable book." - Elizabeth Marshall Thomas "In this excellent exploration of the conflict between animal protection and animal research, the author resolutely resists simplistic answers.... By showing the spectrum of possible views between the moral absolutism of one camp and the unrepentant materialism of the other, this valuable book suggests a vast ground for compromise." - The New Yorker "U.S. scientists experiment on 14 million animals a year. Do health and safety benefits to humans justify the suffering of animals? Deborah Rudacille addresses the issue with fairness and respect to both science and its critics." - Rob Mitchell, Boston Globe "Must reading for biomedical researchers and indeed for anyone concerned about the ethics of human and animal experimentation. Rudacille is fair to both camps - she exposes both the merits and the weaknesses of the animal rights advocates and of the researchers, and tellingly recounts changes in our attitudes over time that dramatically illustrate the need for open minds and the willingness to change behavior when warranted by the evidence. - Louis Lasagna, Tufts University School of Medicine

Write a review

There are currently no reviews for this book. Be the first to review this book!


Deborah Rudacille was researcher/writer at the Johns Hopkins Center for Alternatives to Animal Testing from 1992 to 1997. She is the coauthor of Animals and Alternatives in Testing: History, Science and Ethics (1994).

Bestsellers in this subject

Downward Causation and the Neurobiology of Free Will

NHBS Price: £89.99 $119/€101 approx

The Animals' Agenda

NHBS Price: £13.99 $18/€16 approx

A Sand County Almanac

NHBS Price: £8.99 $12/€10 approx

The Meaning of Human Existence

NHBS Price: £10.99 $15/€12 approx

VAT: GB 407 4846 44
NHBS Ltd is registered in England and Wales: 1875194